Too much emphasis is placed on the financial aspects of corporate governance, with boards typically having insufficient HR expertise and focus on critical people issues. 

CIPD response to code consultation  

This was a key message in the CIPD’s response to the Financial Reporting Council’s consultation on changes to the UK Corporate Governance Code. The consultation was launched following the publication of the government’s white paper Restoring trust in audit and corporate governance.  

The CIPD’s response, which was informed by discussions with senior HR members, supported the overall direction of the suggested amendments to the code, for example, to focus more on outcomes focused reporting and further emphasise the importance of boards overseeing actions to embed culture. We also welcomed proposals to widen emphasis in the code on equality, diversity and inclusion beyond just gender and ethnicity.  

However, we highlighted that there was still too much emphasis on financial rather than people governance and expertise. We disagreed with the proposal in the consultation that the remit of audit committees should be expanded to include narrative reporting, including sustainability reporting, and where appropriate ESG metrics. In our view, there isn’t sufficient expertise and knowledge about ESG matters within most audit committees and they are unlikely to have the capacity to take on this expanded role.   

Key recommendations  

There is a need for the code to highlight the importance of organisations considering the balance of skills and experience of the whole board as a team, in addition to the skills of the individual members, and to explain how the team make-up matches the challenges faced by the company.  

We further recommended that only ‘objective criteria’ should be used in the context of succession planning in the code, rather than ‘merit’, to reflect best practice. We also called out the need for director training on EDI.   

As part of our submission, we included the CIPD report on the value of people expertise on boards published in July 2023 which highlighted common errors made by boards from the perspective of chief people officers.  

 

 

  

About the author

Susannah Haan, Senior Corporate Governance Adviser, CIPD

Susannah is the Senior Corporate Governance Adviser at the CIPD, having worked for companies, investors and regulators to influence public policy and create long-term change, improving corporate and investor reporting and accountability to company shareholders and investor clients. 

She originally developed an interest in the area when working with company chairmen at the CBI on the Higgs Review of the role and responsibilities of non-executive directors.

She has worked in London, Moscow and Brussels. Previous roles include: board member at PWN Global, business angel at Rising Tide Europe, Secretary General at EuropeanIssuers, Adviser to the Financial Reporting Council on the introduction of the Stewardship Code for institutional investors, Associate Director of Public Policy at Fidelity International, Senior Legal Adviser at Clifford Chance and Lawyer at Clifford Chance. 

She is also a Trustee of the CBI Retirement Fund and Advisory Board member to PWI Brussels.

More on this topic

Factsheet
The non-executive director role

Learn how non-executive directors (NEDs) differ from executive directors and how they operate within an organisation

For Members
Factsheet
Corporate responsibility: An introduction

This factsheet explores corporate responsibility and putting it into action in the workplace

For Members
Factsheet
Modern slavery

Learn what modern slavery is, as well as HR's role in preventing and tackling it

For Members
CIPD Viewpoint
Responsible business

Explore the CIPD’s point of view on responsible business, including recommendations for employers

More thought leadership

Thought leadership
Analysis | Proposed changes to unfair dismissal rules risk more insecure work

Meaningful consultation is needed to ensure the Employment Rights Bill delivers intended outcomes, says Ben Willmott, CIPD Head of Public Policy

Thought leadership
Briefing | After recent claims, where next for equal pay?

Charles Cotton, CIPD senior adviser on pay and reward, explains the recent cases on equal pay claims and explores how you can protect yourself as an employer while also paying people fairly

Thought leadership
UK employment law round-up: September 2024

Monthly round-up of changes in employment law in the UK

Thought leadership
Critical role of HR business partnering in HR operating models

How can people teams balance line managers’ need for operational people management support while growing their team’s strategic influence through the HRBP role?