Transcript[Intro Music Plays]
Teaser 1: “I had one of those first experiences where you've probably seen them online with somebody's got something attached to the screen. They're giving me really good answers. And I'm thinking you're sounding robotic, you're a bit too perfect. What's going on here?”
Teaser 2: “I don't necessarily think there's a correlation that automatically goes more investment, therefore means that you are being more strategic.”
Teaser 3: “I had a conversation yesterday with one of our main contractors who are bringing back the assessment centre. Well, I nearly fell off my chair. I nearly fell off my chair.
“I love an assessment centre.”
“Who doesn't?”
“It gives me the ick. It gives me the ick.”
“Navy suits, assessment centres.”
Teaser 4: “Everybody listening to this today, please take note, unless the people reports to the chief executive, you are never going to be able to unlock the performance and potential in your organisation. I fundamentally believe that…”
[Intro Music Fades]
Leah De Silva (LDS): Hello and welcome to the HR People Pod, the CIPD's fortnightly podcast bringing you expert insight and topical stories affecting the people profession and the world of work. My name is Leah De Silva. I'm a senior program manager within the CIPD Trust. We are the social impact arm of the CIPD, transforming access to work through the power of the people profession. And I'm delighted to welcome to the studio today. Two fabulous guests, so let's do some introductions.
David Blackburn (DB): Thank you, Leah. My name is David Blackburn. I'm a Chartered Companion of the CIPD. Next year I'll have been an HR professional for 30 years. Three years ago, I set up my own consultancy. I work with a range of different clients and I'm currently working with the Bar Standards Board and the regulator of social housing.
LDS: Fabulous.
Rob Rees (RR): I'm Rob Rees. I'm currently the Head of People for a design, mechanical and electrical engineering company called Dowds. And I am a Chartered Fellow of the CIPD and been in the profession for about 10 years. So not very inferior to David's companionship and his excellent career.
DB: It's only because I'm older.
RR: You still look 21, David. You still look 21.
LDS: Excellent.
DB: Rob can come on again.
LDS: And he will. And talking of that, the eagle-eared, I don't know if that's a word, but it is now. The eagle-eared listeners amongst you will know that this is not your first time on the pod. So, David, this is your sixth appearance.
RR: It is.
LDS: And Rob, your third. So, a very warm welcome.
RR: I think my probably my second because the first was online. So, I'm not sure whether the online version still counts.
LDS: Oh, it counts, it definitely counts. Excellent.
And regular listeners will know that the stories we touch on today are very much used as a jumping off point. We can't possibly know all the context and the detail that sits behind everything.
let's jump in because actually the first topic is all around. I hope you've read it at home. If you haven't, we will post the links as well. The CIPD has recently published its annual HR Pulse report for the year. And this basically looks at a deep dive into all the priorities for the profession, everything from AI adoption through to career progression and some of the everyday concerns affecting the profession.
Now, one trend that sort of stood out is that functions with stronger investment are associated with more strategic activity and positive internal reputations. I'm not going to read out all the stats because we will post the link so that you can have a look at the report at home. But there's this interesting element where reduced budgets might mean for more people teams, they feel less likely to be a strategic partner, less focused on improving productivity. And I wanted to unpack that a little bit with both of you, this idea that you need to invest to be more strategic and why some of the people functions seem to be so sensitive to budget. You know, what is that investment doing? Is it buying capability, credibility.
DB: I mean, it's a fascinating topic, isn't it? And it feels like, I mean, it's not a new topic.
LDS: No?
DB: I don't necessarily think, so I'll say up front, I'm not sure that investment equals you being more strategic or more strategic capability. I don't think the two things are now if your organisation thinks that you are a strategic people function and you are adding strategic value and you're making the organisation more productive and you probably have a chief people officer or an HR director who is on the executive. Well then, you probably are getting more investment. But I don't necessarily think there's a correlation that automatically goes more investment, therefore means that you are being more strategic.
What is it that you're investing in is the thing that's really interesting in the data, which people can see in the report. But for example, if you take OD, you know, take that as a skill set, I've worked with lots of organisations and clients where, you know, either it doesn't exist, or if it does exist, it's not necessarily in the right place in the organisational structure. Or they think they need it, but they don't actually know what it is or what it does. Or with one client, which I particularly liked, they'd just done a big restructure of the people function, got rid of all the OD skill set, and then six months later were restructuring the whole organisation. And I was like, so those OD people that you got rid of, that might be really helpful.
So I think it comes back to, and it's an old chestnut, in order to be taken seriously and to be considered strategic function, what is the conversation that's happening at an executive level? You know, do you think that your HR professionals and your people function are transactional or transformational? You know, are they driving the business strategy and shaping the business strategy or are they simply responding to it? And I think my experience that's the difference that's the fundamental now investment often then follows out of that because if you're having the right conversations about and I'll… Because I could talk about this all day.
But I'll say one more thing, which is, learning and development, for example, all of these, the specialisms that I think very often are seen as the first things to be cut, the easiest thing to put a red line through. Let's not do any of that. You know, my call to, fellow L&D professionals is that I think often one of the reasons is because we're not very good at articulating the return on the investment.
LDS: Ok
DB: You know, is the, you know, we're spending a lot of money on leadership development, what, is it changing the culture? Is it changing leadership behaviour? Are we doing those sorts of things? So many organisations, it's not just about the restructure or the reorganisation. It's all to do with culture. And CEOs, we all know this. And CEOs say we need to fix the culture. Culture's been on the CEO's agenda for the last decade. And yet at the same time, there's a disconnect, isn't there? Then the first thing you go is, oh, let's cut all the learning development stuff. And I'm going, well, you've just worked out that actually you need to upskill your leaders in order to be more productive. That's not a people thing. That's an organisational thing. And then you've cut all of those budgets and you've cut those things. So, I think there isn't a direct link. I think in order, you need to make the strategic argument in order to win the investment.
LDS: Interesting.
RR: If you look at some of the press, you've got some of these tech bros in Silicon Valley who are making headlines because they've sacked their entire HR team and their entire HR squad and you're thinking, right, okay, this is going to be interesting. And one article that I read, they sacked them because they felt that they were producing the problems. And in the teams that I've both been part of and both been led by that have the biggest budgets or the biggest executive support have been where, as David articulates, that we are driving change.
LDS: Yeah.
DB: Yeah.
RR: And where, as somebody who has to manage and lead those HR professionals, it's very easy for us to get in the weeds dealing with a [inaudible] that nobody sees unless it goes really wrong. And we end up in a very public facing tribunal that everybody sees, but nobody sees what happens behind the closed door. So that's not very public.
But then if you look at other organisations, CPOs and other HRDs are getting AI and change transformation added to their brief. So that tells me that There's two sides to this coin. There's very much a transactional way of trying to lead by legislation. And we've got to do this because there's tick box exercise and the government are telling us that we need to do this. And I'm reading that this is best practice. And you know, you say best practice to a CEO and they're going to go, that's not how you influence at a board at all. Right the way through to somebody who's obviously, as David very articulately said, driving transformation. They're actually getting the AI brief, they're getting the productivity brief. They are having a much wider remit than just staying in their lane.
And I think I'm in post at Dowds for just shy of 18 months. And one of the red lines that I had joining the organisation, because I was coming from an organisation where I absolutely loved what I was doing and I left the job that was so close to my heart. But there was one big red line to me accepting this job and that was reporting to the CEO because I knew that if I had that place on the board, if I had that direct link to Louise, that I could really buy into her vision understand what it's like to be led by her. And she's one of the only female CEOs in construction. She's a visionary. She's really, really determined that we will succeed. And having that real drive and that support to make that change allows my team to be at the forefront of, right, we want to make this change well. Let's not go and talk to our supply chain who can help us do that. Let's go and understand the people piece first in terms of how we unlock that from a skills perspective and how we change the behaviour of that person.
We were talking earlier, Leah, around, I can't remember what we were specifically talking about, she was talking about lots, but we were talking about putting things on walls like values and admitting to failure and all of that good stuff. But you can't do that unless you teach people how to be comfortable with failure and put in the systems to allow them to openly share about failure. And that's just one example building on what David said around how important culture is being part of our brief if we want to be that transformational function.
LDS: Amazing.
DB: Oh, Rob and I are going to be agreeing with each other all morning. I get the sense.
But just a couple of things. It's so interesting, isn't it? You're absolutely right that, you know, that thing about what's behind the curtain. Too often the problem is, and we also as professionals, HR professionals, are not always the best advocates and ambassadors for our own work. Because what people notice is they notice it when it goes wrong. So actually, what they don't see is the huge amount of effort, and time that goes into keeping it on track and it being right, you know nine times out of ten. You know, so and actually that's really difficult because it's all confidential. You can't share it and all those sorts of things. So, I absolutely always have thought, that's partly the problem. Like, oh, it's gone wrong. And then everyone goes, oh, that's HR over there. You know, actually, how do we get better at saying, the people keeping the wheels from the bus and keeping the engine going is us. We're absolutely central to that.
And my second observation is about your CEO sounds amazing.
LDS: She really does.
DB: And one of the things that I say to, since I've become a consultant and actually in both of my two last roles as chief people officer, I clawed my way onto the executive in both of my last two organisations. I wasn't on the executive when I was appointed, and I clawed my way. And now when I talk to clients, I always say, and everybody listening to this today, please take note, unless the people reports to the chief executive, you are never going to be able to unlock the performance and potential in your organisation. I fundamentally believe that doing this 30 years.
If reporting into a chief of staff, no. If reporting into a chief finance officer, hell no. If reports, you know, I mean, it reporting into a chief operating officer, maybe, but you know, I just think, that the relationship that you end up building, you know, the thing that I've most valued in my career is the relationships I've had with CEOs. Where you actually go, we're hand and glove together to drive change. And I think the more we can do that.
And actually, can I say one last thing? AI, your point about AI, absolutely. It's a great book. It's one of my Bibles. Professor Alan Watkins, Change the Workplace, Change the World: The HR (R)Evolution. He's always said, that's why I quote him, we should be driving a strategy. We shouldn't be responding to it. You know, and I'm absolutely right. AI is not about the technology. It's about how your people are going to use it and what they're going to use it for.
LDS: Absolutely.
DB: I know we'll say something about it in a bit.
RR: I think the really interesting point that you made there, and I was searching there in something you said, you were saying we agree and we obviously agree on that. I said, what can I disagree with? But I think good, great HR, good, great people operations, good commercially signed client operations. We aren't at the centre of our people and our client, and this is Louise's mantra that kind of cut me open and you'll see these words imprinted at the moment because it's all I talk about, is keeping our people and our client at the heart of what we do, even when that curtain's closed.
And one of the things that is so easy to do is to make the easy decision to send the easy e-mail, to do the easy thing, to do the comfortable thing. But what we're doing different, especially in construction, because construction is a very, very, how to put it diplomatically, a very traditional industry. We love a navy suit. Hence why I'm wearing a different colour stake because I have aversion to a navy suit. But construction is very traditional and it will be very cutthroat. But we can be different. We can be our unique selves by making sure that our client and our people are at the heart of what we do. And whether it be our head of operations or our head of finance or our head of IT or me, we are focused centrally around, what does that mean for our people? And what does that mean for our clients? Because if we can't be there for our people, our people can't be there for our clients. And if our clients aren't successful, then we're not successful.
LDS: Excellent. I'm going to move us on because I feel like I'm going to have my work cut out today, but you know, I'm going to give it my best.
DB: We did warn you.
LDS: You absolutely did.
Going back to what David said about unlocking potential, and I think you talked about good HR, great HR, the next topic we're going to unpick is really whether or not we need to rethink how we recruit.
So, this is on the back of the Employment Rights Act changes that have affected rules on unfair dismissal. And of course, from the start of next year, employers will be able to claim that after six months rather than the current two years. So, with that in mind, obviously, that is creating this kind of fear of bad hiring or poor practice. And rather than course correcting that, people are trying to prevent that.
So, I guess the question is, if we are bearing in mind these legislative changes coming in next year, how are we equipping or better equipping hiring managers to make the right choices when they're recruiting?
RR: I think to answer your question, sorry, I'm just jumping in there because I feel quite strongly about this.
LDS: Yeah, no do.
RR: We need to dial up slightly because we need to influence the Secretary of State. We need to influence government to a certain degree because I talked about systems and processes to allow people to fail. Systems and processes aren't there at the moment.
You phone ACAS to do something very, very simple and straightforward and they've got a nine-week backlog. That isn't good for the country. It's not good for the economy. It's not good for the labour market in general. And we can do better. We can absolutely do better if that system is easier and then don't even get me started on the backlog. Thankfully, we're not in that backlog, but to think about how that must be for an employer or an employee going through an industrial tribunal or employment claim, geez, that's a lengthy delay. And unless that system is fixed, all you're doing by doing that, by giving more access to that and not having that gateway is just a recipe for disaster in my unbiased opinion.
I think our hiring managers are absolutely key because if we then start at the other end before anything goes wrong, because that's where the root cause tends to sit. If our job design is right from our perspective, if we've got our hiring manager bought into what that job looks like, ticking the box because that gives you a really good clear insight into what type of person you're looking for, what that skill set needs to be and how can we think about that differently?
We had a conversation outside David, around different industry bodies and how those qualifications mix. I think that's a great point in terms of how are we looking at a really rigid set or does another qualification give us what we need?
And then secondly, really supporting our hiring managers to have a conversation. Because I think it's like buzzword bingo in here today. But and I don't think I know, that where candidates are falling down, especially early careers, early careers candidates are falling down is because they are using AI A lot. And I had my very first experience quite recently whilst we were doing some graduate recruitment to join my direct team. And I had one of those first experiences where you've probably seen them online with somebody's got something attached to the screen. They're giving me really good answers. And I'm thinking you're sounding robotic, you're a bit too perfect. What's going on here? And it was very rigid.
And then when I said, so, you know, tell me a little bit about you, they completely and utterly froze. Obviously, I didn't ask that question in that directness, but I wanted to have a flavour about what their ambitions were. They completely did not have any answer because the AI bot that was helping them, I suspect, fell down slightly. So, I think we are coming full circle.
I had a conversation yesterday with one of our main contractors who are bringing back the assessment centre. Well, I nearly fell off my chair. I nearly fell off my chair.
DB: I love an assessment centre.
LDS: Who doesn't?
RR: It gives me the ick. It gives me the ick.
LDS: Navy suits, assessment centres.
But I think we are coming full circle in terms of really understanding a basic application form. Why do you want this job? I know that's simple, but simplicity works and then bringing them in and seeing their eyeballs is totally, totally underrated in my view at the moment.
And then for those more senior roles that we're recruiting, we have great people in our business that can do a quality check at the end. Either, the CEO, who again is very passionate about a number of different things. If we connect her into the recruitment process, we know we see more conversion, we know we see more success. Our non-exec directors who are fab and very, very, very experienced in their field. They're also great to have a quality coffee or a quality check on that candidate. And you've seen that investment up front.
So, it's not just HR supporting the process. HR supporting the process at the start, the hiring manager supporting them to make the initial shortlist and then involving the other business. And we're the facilitator or the conductor of the orchestra, if you like, to pull all of that together. And I think if we can think about that as an experience, that's where we need to go.
DB: There's definitely, isn't there something about the facilitator of the process as opposed to the owner of the decision and that sort of thing? You know, you recruit the business, it's a business decision and the hiring manager.
RR: Absolutely
DB: So, a few thoughts, I think, having to sit on the parliamentary steering group of the Better Hiring Institute and the Better Hiring Institute is about making better hiring decisions in the UK. The system is broken and the system is broken in no matter which bit of the system you look at, I think. You know, it's from a recruitment agency perspective, tries to regulate things, but we all know from our own experience, there is a massive plethora from really, really bad to, you know, really quite good and everything in between.
I was at a roundtable discussion yesterday where we were literally talking about AI applications. So, in the housing sector, you know, a wash, you know, think say 400 applicants on average what it is for every job, how many of those have been written by AI?
And in the same way, to pick up on your point about, the backlog and ACAS and thing, it's three years according to employment lawyers now for central London to get to the employment tribunal. And one of the reasons is that actually people are using the increase in claims is also because they're using AI to fill out their forms. You know, I mean, it's just, you know, so…
But I also think that I love an, I genuinely, I do love an assessment of the centre. And I do think that you're absolutely right about you need to look people in the eye. There is something about the value. Now, equally, I get concerned about then how long we make the process, because, you know, one of the tendencies the last couple of years, especially for senior roles, is that, you know, he's stage seven, because by the time you've done one interview, then another interview, then another interview, three panel interviews, then you've met the chair, then you've had a fireside chat with some of the board members, then you think, I mean, and I'm not joking because I know people have told me that's the length thing. So, I think it's got to be proportionate. I think it's got to be right. But I do think, you know, aptitude, all those old things that we used to talk about, aptitude and ability tests and all those sorts of things, I think are important because, you know, and getting people in and testing them with real scenarios and all of that sort of stuff.
RR: And I think that you're completely right in terms of a long process, whether you're recruiting a director or you're recruiting a graduate, keep that process long, you're going to lose them. And that's where the tech sector do it really well for me is that they have a really agile approach. And one of the things that's been driven by Louise's vision really is about reducing the amount of layers between here and the shop floor. So here and here and our PMs and our construction managers, there's no more than three.
DB: Nice, I like that.
LDS: I do.
DB: I do.
RR: So, we're really nimble, we're really agile, we're able to get things done from a recruitment perspective quickly because this is where the whole people experience comes into it. I think. Absolutely, 100% right.
LDS: Yeah.
DB: That's the other last thing I remember mate was actually when you're saying, actually, you do need to apply the experience lens to it. How, so often I think, back to one of the conversations we were having earlier about people designing processes, and then you go, this process is fundamental, it doesn't make any sense. You know, it's actually going, if you were a candidate, what is your experience of going through that? Because sometimes we also forget, you know, it is a two-way dialogue. You know, it's not, they are also going, do I want to work for this organisation? So are you doing the utmost to go, I'm going to get the best candidate because they're going to have a great experience. They're thinking, I'm really excited about joining or going, oh dear God, here's the internal next 19th stage of this process. You know, it's, you know, so I just think experience is sometimes the bit that we forget when we're designing something sometimes for ourselves as opposed to designing it for the candidate.
LDS: For the candidate.
RR: And David, do you think there's an issue with when you've got a seven-stage process, is the issue the leadership's ability to make a decision or is there some other reason that we're not seeing? Is there a blind spot here that we're not seeing?
DB: I think it's both. I think so. Sometimes it's, is it being prioritised by hiring managers? So, I've got 4,000 things going on. I've just done a restructure. I've got lots of vacancies. Oh my God, you know, I've got the time to do it and therefore they're being chased by HR.
LDS: Yeah.
DB: And you know, I think sometimes there is definitely something about unicorn candidates. I loved what you said about, actually, if you get people involved right at the start of the process, you get your people, professionals and the hiring manager working together to design the job.
LDS: Yeah.
DB: You know, because too often I have conversations with clients and they say, and we want to spread to this, this, this and this. And I say that person doesn't exist. You know, you are literally looking for a unicorn. You know that is not that, you know, whereas let's try and work out what are the three things that you think they can't be a lawyer and an accountant. I'm sure some of those people do exist somewhere, but they're not easy to find.
And I think there's both, so I think it's both time constraint, prioritisation, but often, my key is always, the more you involve your people professionals at the start of a process, the better. You want the conversation that happened right at the start, not ta-da, here's some role profile that I've drafted, and can you go and find me somebody?
LDS: So, I think that what we're coming off with, the key is balance. And also, if you're looking for someone at the start of the process, they may well be senior by the end of stage 19. Yes. Who knows?
Taking that on board and thinking about how people work together, we've got some hot off the press recommendations. So being brilliant in the HR People Pod and having two brilliant experts, we're able to pivot and deal with this new information.
So, news is surfacing in recent days from the Equality and Human Rights Commission proposing that workers should have a legal right to know their colleagues pay to help prevent pay discrimination. So, what they're calling for is effectively greater transparency, things like colleagues pay, possibly bonuses, overtime.
I'm really keen to know what you think about this, you know, and do we think having more transparency might reduce pay discrimination or will it create additional tensions? What do we think, Rob?
RR: I think we need to get the basics right as a, I think not we, the government need to get the basics right before they do anything else. We obviously operate in Northern Ireland or the north of Ireland, whichever you want to describe it as. And since the Windsor framework, the Windsor framework has given us a melting pot of confusion.
DB: Casserole of nonsense is one of my favourite faces.
RR: That was much more articulate.
LDS: I like both of those because they are culinary analogies as well.
RR: So, we still have the gender pay gap reporting, everything that comes under the EU in terms of the work time directives, things that haven't been moved across in terms of the legislation that's come out of Westminster.
So yes, I agree that Pay transparency is a good thing. But I also think we're further ahead than we actually believe we are with this topic. And the last thing we need is as wealth creators, as opportunity facilitators, whatever words you want to use the private sector for, without putting more red tape in the way of innovation and without putting more red tape around the economy, there's a better way of doing this. And I think the better way of doing that is by organisations really keeping their people at the heart of what they do and understanding, right, how much is that skill worth? Is that fair? And is everybody on a level playing field?
DB: I think that it's the key in your question, Leah, was the saying, you know, they're saying that they think by doing this or by enforcing it, will reduce pay discrimination. And it's a bit like where we came in at the first question about, you know, strategic and investment. I'm not sure that there's a that's the correlation.
So, you know, I think, and I think, you know, it's slightly ironic that the oldest piece of discrimination legislation on the statute is the Equal Pay Act of 1970. And here we are in 2026 talking about it.
I think that, so I absolutely think that pay transparency, I agree with Rob, I think pay transparency is a good thing. And we were talking earlier, it already exists in lots of sectors. It exists very clearly in the public sector. It's very easy for people to see what band that they sit in, not necessarily the exact pay that a colleague, but if you've got incremental spinal points and grades and all that sort of stuff, it's pretty easy to work it out. I think it's about fairness. I absolutely think it's about fairness. And I don't, yeah.
So, for me, it's more that, you know, it's the action, what's the thing that you're trying to achieve? So, if it's about pay discrimination, I'm not sure that's the lever that you won't necessarily want to pull. Intervention when you do set, I'm going to give you a real example from my experience. I was the Chief People Officer of the Financial Services Compensation Scheme for 10 years. And in the 10 years that I was there, we turned our gender pay gap from 18.4 per cent in favour of males to 1.5 per cent in favour of women. And you know, and how do we do that? Because we signed the Women in Finance Charter and we had to report on it every year and they and that's it. So, in minutes it becomes a, so there was something about it being monitored and there were requirements. So, the organisation got focused on it.
I agree with Rob, that I'm not sure that this action, if the government suddenly said, this is what you must do, that it's the right thing. And then, and that's before we get into thinking about unintended consequences and all the other stuff, to your point about tension and what do you mean, the paid ‘X’, you know, going on and a driver ER cases. I mean, I can see it now, can't you? So, you know, joy.
LDS: I'm going to bring us on to our last topic for the day, which has actually been inspired by a post from you, Rob, on LinkedIn. Obviously, we touched on AI a little bit and its impact on all our lives. But one of the things you were posting about is if it's become such a big part of our lives now. What's its impact on our ability to think critically? And obviously critical thinking is at the heart of the CIPD's approach to evidence-led approaches in its work, but also, it's critical for people professionals. So, tell us a bit more about the impact that that's having and why you think we need to discuss that.
RR: I've got this thing, and this is why I asked David a second ago about decision making. I really feel we are losing the ability as a population to make a decision. It scares me to think of how many decisions we make because we put it into Claude or we put it into ChatGPT or put it into Co-Pilot. Many others exist, but they're obviously the most common. And it scares me that we're losing the ability to make a decision.
And just because I haven't got enough to do, I, the post that you allude to, I was refereeing a game of rugby back in Northern Ireland and somebody in the bar afterwards said to me, how does it feel to make a decision after you've just ran 50 metres? And I was like, and then I was driving back and I was thinking, how does it feel to make a decision in work when it's emotive, it affects somebody and it's a bit grey? I'm quite happy with that. I'm quite comfortable in that space, because I've done my academic training. I've got the experience of getting it wrong as well as getting it right. And I'm not afraid to own it if it goes wrong. because that's what I'm paid to do.
But then it made me think about my team and how much my team defer to me. And then I had a conversation with my boss about it and Louise was like, are we trusting them to get it wrong? Do they feel trusted to get it wrong? And I still don't know the answers to that, but I suspect, and I'm not necessarily talking about my team because no doubt they will listen to this, but I worry as an organisation how many things we don't know and instead of asking and having a conversation anymore, we just plug it in to ChatGPT or a like, rather than thinking back to the profession map by saying like I'm a CIPD puppet now, but I'm genuinely not. If we think back to the profession map, one of the key bases of decision making is evidence-based decisions. It's so simple and it is at the heart of our profession map, and it scares me to death that we're losing it. And that's why the post came about.
DB: It doesn't quite scare me to death, I don't think, but I if I knock on my microphone because I’ll get up and hugged Rob at this point. The really, the thing that does scare me is, evidence-based practice is absolutely at the centre. And then I find, actually I have conversations with people and I'm reminding them that that's at the centre. You know, you're saying, and they're like, what's this great big thing you do? So, in the current project I'm working on, you know, I did three months of discovery, you know, and, you know, and so that when I produce it, I say, this is completely evident. This is completely what I I’m telling you what I'm recommending, what I think should be the next stages, you know, is rooted in evidence.
So, I think you're right. There's a sort of creep away from going, you know, and again, the sort of time constraint and the ease of speed and all, you know, that sort of stuff that, you know, if the default becomes, I'm asking the bot, I'm asking AI, not I'm asking a colleague, not I'm asking a peer, not. And but one of the things that Rob said that really resonates with me. You know, trust is so incredibly important. The Investors in People earlier, about two months ago, published a report on it, the IP organisations. Anyone who's ever heard me speak, I'm obsessed by it. I've been talking about it for 10 years. I am a devotee of the work of Stephen MR Covey. So, if you haven't read The Speed of Trust or Trust and Inspire, you know, he basically says that's what good organisations get right.
And if we're creating a space, I think right at the beginning, you were saying, are we allowing our people to fail and learn from it? Are we allowing our people to learn lessons? Do they feel safe? Do they feel accountable?
RR: It's about being vulnerable.
DB: Isn't it? And I also love the thing is, you know, getting comfortable with discomfort and ambiguity is absolutely the way, you know, and I think one of the things that you, now I'm a senior, I guess that's the right word, senior professional, because I've been doing it for so long, that very, very little is black and white. that's the one thing that you learn. You start out going, oh, it's this or it's that and it's not. Very, very little is binary. You know, the vast majority of complex organisational decisions are sitting in that murky grey space. But there is an expectation that you are going to be making, you've got the answer. And I think there's both being vulnerable to say, put your hand up and go, I don't know. I'm always doing that. even as a consultant, I'm going, I haven't, you know, I'm not a magician. I don't know some of, you know, I need to go for a way and find out what the answer is. But I think, you know, there's, I think the thing that we're going to have to work out how we navigate in these future years is, you know, what are we using? You know, it's an amazing tool.
LDS: Of course.
DB: But it shouldn't be replacing our ability, our human ability. And it's just reminded me what I said earlier, we're just kick over coffee, was the World Economic Forum Skills Outlook. So, they publish a report every year. And AI, it comes in at #11. It's not even in the top 10. And the top five are all cognitive behavioural skills, analytical thinking, resilience, flexibility and agility, leadership and social influence, creative thinking, motivation and self-awareness. Human just leadership decision making skills.
RR: There's an exact reason why people retire from an executive career and train to be a coach and a mentor because you can't replace the human connection of having a coach who can help you think differently and having a mentor who's been there, done it and got the t-shirt. Because if you're vulnerable and open to that, you'll build and build and build.
LDS: And at that point, I'm going to bring us to a close because this has been fascinating. I didn't expect us to cover buzzword bingo, navy suits, casseroles of nonsense, and for AI not to make the top ten. Casseroles of nonsense is a trademark phrase to change. There are other sayings available.
But for me, just a huge thank you for both of you for being so candid, so brilliant today. A huge thank you to our listeners. And don't forget, wherever you subscribe to us, do, because you can catch up on episodes you've missed, and you can also listen to the new ones as they drop every fortnight.
We'll of course publish all the resources and reports we've referred to today, but it just remains for me to say that I've been Leah De Silva, and this has been the HR People Pod.
[Outro Music Plays]